Hi, I'm Kat McCoy

I help people buy and make special pieces of jewelry

About Me
Young female entrepreneur business owner  sitting at desk looking at Apple computer  screen
Handmade diamond choker necklace layered  with personalized yellow gold necklace over  simple white blouse on young woman
Handcrafted 18k yellow gold antique locket  necklace with beaded design on cream silk  blanket
Female woman entrepreneur sitting in  office in a computer chair in front of library  of books posing with jewelry


I specialize in sourcing jewelry for a range of occasions including engagements, birthdays, holidays, anniversaries, push presents, bridal parties, and more.

I work with top designers, jewelers, wholesalers, and collectors to find my clients the best pieces at the best prices.

My job is to make the process of buying jewelry easy and stress-free.

How does it work?

thin gold chain diamond pendant fine jewelry


During a brief phone call, we'll discuss what kind of jewelry you're looking for and who the recipient is.

Review your personally curated recommendations

You'll receive 3-5 unique options to choose from that perfectly match what you're looking for. I visit stores, call partners and take pictures as I hunt for the best options available.

Get Started

Receive your piece of jewelry

The purchasing, wrapping, and delivery of your gift is personally handled with care.

Best Kept packaging giftwrapping with gold  foil gift bag with logo and branded gold pouch  with hand-written note

The Best Kept Philosophy

A piece of jewelry should be well-made and well-priced, but most of all, it needs to reflect the style of whoever will be wearing it.

When you get it right, jewelry is one of the most meaningful purchases you can make.

My promise to you is that we're going to get it right.

Get Started

Buying jewelry should be exciting.  It's an investment in love, legacy, and style.  And like any great investment, committing to the final purchase can feel like a leap.

I created Best Kept to help you make that leap with confidence. Whether you're designing an engagement ring, searching for an unforgettable gift, or want to add something special to your collection, together we'll find just what you need.

best kept (adj.)

1. delightful for its beauty and emotional significance

2. meant to be cherished, often passed down between generations

As Seen On


Happy blonde couple, newly engaged with  woman flashing her yellow gold diamond  engagement ring5 stone diamond and yellow gold engagement  ring on woman’s finger posing at a bar to show  her friends

"I could not be happier with my stunning engagement ring! My fiancé was extremely thoughtful and wanted to re-create a meaningful family ring for me. He had a clear vision but was so appreciative to have Kat's help with the details like the 4C's, basket, prongs, etc. It turned out better than I could have imagined!"

"I worked with Kat on a pair of diamond earrings for my girlfriend's birthday. The process couldn't have been easier - we spoke over the phone then texted back and forth a few times to go through the options. I knew I wanted something classic and Kat took care of the rest."

White gold and diamond circular earring  clusters with post back in simple and elegant  settingYoung stylish woman in orange floral dress  posing at brunch wearing diamond stud earrings

"My wife always wanted a Cartier Tank watch so before our son was born I reached out to see if we could track down a vintage one as a 'push present.' The market for watches is confusing and I didn't want to get hustled. Kat was able to find me a mint condition Tank in the box with papers for a much better price than any I found in all of my research."

"I came to Kat to find gifts to ask my sisters to be my co-maids of honor. Within days she found these gold cuff bracelets that I could personalize with their initials. My sisters love them. I love working with Kat - she finds the best stuff."

Personalized bangle bracelets engraved  with coordinates, roman numerals, and initials,  tri-tone mixed metal bands

"Kat selected an 18k rose gold and diamond clover necklace for me. It's so 'me' - I wear it everyday, I feel like it's my good luck charm."

Get Started


How much should I plan to spend?

I work with budgets of all sizes to find you the best value possible.  Since I focus on special pieces with real gemstones, Best Kept budgets start at $500.

What types of clients do you work with?

I work with anyone who wants to buy a piece of jewelry for themselves or a loved one.  Husbands, mothers, daughters, sisters, brothers, friends, boyfriends, cousins, you name it.

How long does it take to receive recommendations?

Most clients receive recommendations within 48-72 hours.

Can we commission a custom piece like an engagement ring?

Absolutely! In our phone consultation we’ll discuss what you’re looking to have made.  

What if none of the recommendations are perfect?

It’s so important to me that you feel confident in your purchase.  I’ll work with you to source alternative options until we find just the right piece.

Do I buy the jewelry directly from Best Kept?

Yes! After you make your final selection, I’ll send the wrapped gift with a card for you to sign.

Can I return or exchange my selection?

I want you to love what you’ve purchased.  Exchange policies will vary based on the jewelry designer and the piece.  To confirm if an item is final sale or can be exchanged please email support@bestkept.com.  We do not accept returns.

© 2019 BestKept. All rights reserved. Website by 10011STUDIO.